Is America crazy? The best singer of the bunch and you save Paul McDonald or even James Durbin ( not my favorite), I love Pia, Casey and Scotty, I really thought the final (2) would have her in there. In my heart I know she will still have a career, but then again they voted off Jennifer Hudson way to early and look at her now, an Oscar and Grammy winner...

The people that vote are just nutz!! The most talented, beautiful singer and you vote her off? Now, I really think america has no idea or really doesn't want a talented person as the American Idol. Last season, I do not understand how Lee won over Crystal but who has a video out and an add with BB King? Crystal not Lee, so sometimes it is better not to win..